My BS on a BA
|
"The ultimate goal of the educational system is to
shift to the individual the burden of pursing his own education. This will not
be a widely shared pursuit until we get over our odd conviction that education
is what goes on in school buildings and nowhere else." --John W. Gardner Thank god my naivety never bore fruit. I once believed that education was about a trade--after all, you can't learn to be smart. I look at classes labeled "business leadership" and wonder, "What the f*&k does a 22-year-old, with no experience outside of educational institutions, trained by a (wo)man in a similar situation, know about leading?" Creative writing--how the hell does someone learn to be creative? Isn't "creative writing" just "writing" except done by someone with creativity? I survived a semester in an "Introduction to Business" class being taught by someone who had never managed--much less started--a business. She vehemently argued with me that, even though the book listed a "laissez faire" management style, there was no circumstance in the business world that called for it. Long story short, I had a bitter taste in my mouth when it came to education. It took many hours of frustration under the yoke of my own short-sightedness to relent...a little bit. A few months ago I posed a question on the forums here that elicited a few very thorough responses. For this, I am incredibly grateful. It was unfair of me to pose this question without clarifying my long-standing position on postsecondary education. Unfortunately, it was the content that was lacking in the responses that taught me the most. Not one non-trad stepped forward. The reason I wanted a non-traditional student--someone who attended college at a time other than immediately after high school--is that I wanted to hear from someone who knew what it was like to get by in a world without it. To beg for a professional position without listing a degree, without discussing college courses; to get into a conversation about education, without a story about a dorm roommate. I place a lot of stock in the collective intelligence and capabilities of the Matador network--so when no one stepped forward, it reinforced something that I already suspected: The "uneducated" are eventually silenced. Not literally, of course. The theory that there's a secret society of people who hold liberal arts degrees, whose sole purpose is to block the communications of the uneducated is insane, at best. Allow me to explain. It has been my experience that, for an "uneducated" person to call into question the critical thinking abilities of an "educated" person elicits a communicative blockade. I once jokingly asked a Vice President which course in their MBA magically qualified them to become a VP. It was a joke, because I respected this VP, and didn't question their ability to lead. Uncomfortable laughter was followed by a dismissive "yeah...". College graduates are facing more and more pressure to quantify their four-to-seven years. Their higher education must, under any and all circumstances, qualify them for a job they otherwise wouldn't have been qualified. After all, what was the point of going to college if you are going to be competing against people who didn't go to college? What were those years in the dorm/abroad/at the coffee house for if they don't amount to an average increase in pay? So we, the merely high school educated, learn to keep our mouth shut as a result of constant, subtle interactions in our everyday lives. In this way, the intelligentsia maintains an accidental barrier between themselves and the great unwashed. Now today, I read a lot of insights into cultures and places and see a certain irony. At one turn a writer, usually college-educated, laments the inescapable plight of these poor unwashed; inescapable because they are, of course, too stupid to change their situation or to realize that their situation is bad. Another writer, usually college-educated, extols the undiscovered virtues of acting like these poor unwashed people; what an amazing feat that they find happiness in their dirty, simple lives! Neither of them ever writes and says, "Maybe they're smart enough to choose this." As I stare at my University acceptance letter, I feel both pride and nausea. This is not an issue of self esteem; it's about pushing through a barrier--a barrier that sounds crazy to some, because they have never seen it. Starting in fall 2008, I'm pursuing a bachelor's in English, but for all I feel it matters, it could be a B.A. in Interpretive Dance with a minor in Sexual Economics. I don't mind if I never make a penny more as a result. After all, it’s the journey and not the destination, right? ;) [i]"We must learn to honor excellence in every socially accepted human activity, however humble the activity, and to scorn shoddiness, however exalted the activity. An excellent plumber is infinitely more admirable than an incompetent philosopher. The society that scorns excellence in plumbing because plumbing is a humble activity and tolerates shoddiness in philosophy because it is an exalted activity will have neither good plumbing nor good philosophy. Neither its pipes nor its theories will hold water." --John Gardner[/i] |

This idea first came to my attention back in junior high - one of my brother's friends had dropped out his senior year to start his own business and travel the world. Although my family was definitely envious of his choice in lifestyle, I wouldn't exactly say they were proud... simply because he wasn't following the prescribed "go to school, get good grades, go to college, get a job, retire, then enjoy" plan.
Managing creativity is true, as is simply putting yourself in a new situation. If being in high school incidentally exposes you to new ideas, then university does that 100-fold.
Unfortunately, as the universe is run by the educated and elite, I can't see the high school diploma crowd being granted equality in the professional world. It isn't a question of skills, just a black/white filter when it comes to acceptance: university = interview and chance to prove oneself; high school diploma = come back in a few years or work for less doing the same job.
The education system in Japan is a paragon of this way of thinking. Students are so stressed after completing years of cram schools, entrance exams, and high school classes, that once they enter university, they just relax and party (generalization, but more or less true). The name of the university is what counts, because that name is the result of having studied very, very hard for the proper entrance exam. That name determines where you will end up in the working world, because recruiters know students spend little to no time actually completing the course work in college. So, if you think about it, getting your education in Japan is like entering the professional world with a high school diploma, but the facade of a university degree. As a note side, I don't know how students still graduate without attending class, but they do.
Like Lola said, you might find yourself pleasantly surprised on your "new journey." I'm definitely stoked to hear about your experiences at school for the next few years.
Now I'm thinking about my interactions with the "uneducated" - am I an elitist snob? I'm sure that there's some subconscious twitch that allows me to dismiss the "uneducated" person. I'll have to try to remember to un-twitch it from now on. :)
My face turns red when I reread my own words. My intentions were more geared towards highlighting the extent to which I've clung to outdated beliefs and unfairly isolated/generalized people of an educated nature, than to point the finger at my "oppressors", as it were. I feel there are (wo)men wiser than myself who would be able to forgive this discrepancy without spending four years earning a degree.
I definitely think my travel-, writing- and life-experience opportunities will be greatly augmented by this experience. I'll also have access to health insurance and a decent gym for the first time in a while. ;)
Thanks for the comment!
"health insurance and a decent gym"
Two of the things I miss most about higher education!
Yet another absolutely terrific blog. Good points all around, and you manage to illuminate broader themes through your individual perspective and experience - which is really what it's all about.
One of my best friends dropped out of school in 7th grade. He currently has more business responsibility (managing a ranch in the Idaho panhandle) than any of my friends, with the possible exception of a JP Morgan slave or two.
Thanks Tim! It's funny to think that once upon a time, the measures of success and happiness didn't correlate to office size. Of course, JP Morgan and the halls of business can be as wild and untamed as open plain, no?
"Creative writing--how the hell does someone learn to be creative?"
For the longest time, I felt the same way about people who went to school to become artists. Its either in you or its not.
But through the years, I've realized that you just can't know every little shortcut or trick that can make one's creativity a lot more manageable, and make one more efficient without learning from someone else.
Congrats on your new journey. You just might be pleasantly surprised :).
It's funny--I actually took a creative writing course at tech school. The first assignment was to write about what we think it means to teach/learn creative writing. I wrote an acerbic essay that documented those point that you list--bringing manageability to the creativity we have--that damned the remainder of my time in the class. I think I eek'd by with a C.
If I set my expectations low enough, I'm almost certain to be surprised. ;) Thanks!
"So we, the merely high school educated, learn to keep our mouth shut as a result of constant, subtle interactions in our everyday lives."
It's funny, I'd never realized what a specific set of assumptions (vis a vis life path) I lived with until I was exposed to a few people who'd gone other routes. You might remember a blog I wrote about an Aussie named Ryan who I traveled with in Spain, who really opened my eyes and helped me appreciate travel a lot more. One of the first conversations we had, he was telling me about his cricket team winning state championships, and how the final game was the first time he'd ever worn a suit. Without thinking about it, I said, "But you must have worn a suit to prom, right?" The answer - "I never had a prom, I didn't finish high school" - absolutely silenced me because it was so unexpected in the circumstances (a hostel in Prague).
The bottom line with college, for me anyway, is similar to travel: have fun, and seize every opportunity that comes your way!
I certainly look seizing many opportunities. Would it surprise you to learn that I plan on minoring in "international studies"? What better way to travel with dog/wife/kid than through academia. ;)
Thank you for sharing!
Jacob-
I'm not sure whether congratulations are in order, but I have been wondering what decision you made after that post.
I've been a lot more attentive to looking for writers who didn't attend university and "made it," and every time I find one, I think of you.
Julie-
I am excited about this for a variety of non-ideological reasons and so I graciously accept your congratulations. :) I have you, Eva, Lauren and "Raspberry swirl" to thank for offering a diverse, in depth, and thoroughly useful pool of information from which to ultimately make my decision. Four years and tens of thousands of dollars (not including the addition of a near-daily commute), requires a long, thorough look at our lives as they sit and where are lives will be--not only at the end of the process, but throughout.
Of course, the irony is that I kept this all from my parents and siblings--the reason being that I knew exactly what they were going to tell me and I knew that making this decision required a break from that ingrained ideology. In light of that, seeking the outside opinion became paramount.
I'm curious, which writers have you found that have "made it"? My previous search was based on writers that I, for the most part, enjoy and whose qualities I feel are emulated in my own writing.
I should have kept a written list, because the mental filter didn't hold onto them all! Some of the ones I remember include: Walt Whitman, William Faulkner, and Carl Sandburg.
You might find this interesting:
http://www.education-reform.net/dropouts.htm